HomeMusicAlbumsU2 - Songs of Innocence Review

U2 – Songs of Innocence Review

Rating: 2 out of 5.

Hindsight allows us the beauty of criticising the Songs of… trilogy. Possibly the worst run of albums from U2, though that implies there are any true drop-offs in quality. Even Rattle and Hum had its moments. Songs of Innocence is an enigma of an album, in the sense that it feels bloated yet runs along fast enough to feel like every song is weightless. An ugly collection of work from the Bono-fronted band, which has struggled for some time now in the studio. They have the Weird ‘Al’ Yankovic problem. Issues come and go faster than they can write and record songs speaking to the troubles of the world. Six years of recording, and the overall reaction to Songs of Innocence was: “Can I please remove this from my iPhone? Thanks.” Not a good look for any band, not least one who had spent more than half a decade chipping away at what they believed, up until 2022, was a career-making trilogy.

The Songs Of… project was a disaster to say the least, and you can hear why that is on Songs of Innocence. Underwhelming attempts at reconnecting with their Irish rock roots on songs like The Miracle (Of Joey Ramone) feel out of place after the band’s stadium tour. They can bring it all back home for however long they like, convincing a listener this return to their roots is genuine is half the battle. Fine work from The Edge goes a long way in improving those hopes, his extreme guitar fuzz adds a layer of new instrumental form to the band, but Bono is not at hand to capitalise on that thrill. Instead, it’s a flimsy experience where the frontman says he cannot make sense of the modern world. What, then, was the point of How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb? All the band can do on Songs of Innocence is what they would carry out on Songs of Surrender.  

U2 play up the instrumental tones and notes of their past but haven’t the heart or know how to carry it to exciting new places. Every Breaking Wave is far too close to the preceding ballad meets rock and roll structure. Tiresome is the word for it. Bono becomes the saviour of lost souls once, painting himself as a hero for the new generation, iPhones in hand. That download defines Songs of Innocence more than any of the songs featured. At their very best they offer soft rock tones you will have heard elsewhere that year, let alone in U2’s discography. Empty efforts like California (There Is No End to Love) get no further than repeating the title. That’s it. That’s meant to be Bono’s great proclamation and musing on life. Songs of Innocence is a rare occasion. Few albums which offered so little have ever entered the pop history books quite like this.  

Most of the album is put together well and, on a fundamental level, enjoyable enough. It’s everything around it that struggles. We have heard this tone and style from U2 plenty of times before. Indifference and a lacking detail are what U2 brings out here. Song for Someone is either for Bono’s wife or a chance for him to make up lingering, lovely messages for everyday occurrences. Gone are the staggering commentaries on the world around them and in comes a fleeting, uneventful set of playlist-friendly pieces. U2 has never worked well when light and catchy is the aim, but the likes of Volcano and Raised by Wolves are likeable enough. That’s where the fun stops, though, as the rest of the album, from Cedarwood Road to The Troubles is U2 at their worst. Shlock renditions of their earlier works with little difference from song to song. The Edge stands out, but when does he not? It’s a reduction in quality, and Songs of Innocence is sadly just the start. 


Discover more from Cult Following

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Ewan Gleadow
Ewan Gleadowhttps://cultfollowing.co.uk/
Editor in Chief at Cult Following

READ MORE

LEAVE A REPLY

LATEST