HomeMusicBob Dylan fans share what they think is his 'hardest' song to...

Bob Dylan fans share what they think is his ‘hardest’ song to perform

With so many all-time greats in his discography, Bob Dylan is bound to have a few songs that are tricky to perform.

Fans of the veteran songwriter, who is performing the likes of Tangled Up in Blue and Not Dark Yet on his Lights of Autumn tour in Europe and the United Kingdom, believe they have figured out which songs are the hardest for Dylan to perform. Not only are they tricky for the Mr. Tambourine Man hitmaker but those trying to cover his work are struggling too, with budding instrumentalists noting the complexities of his work in a post to the r/BobDylan subreddit. One fan asked: “What do you think are the hardest Dylan tracks to sing and really capture? In music, there are songs I’d consider totally un-coverable. For example, Led Zeppelin‘s Since I’ve Been Loving You simply cannot be performed well by anyone but them.

“Same goes for Radiohead’s Exit Music (For a Film), or Nude. Disagree with me or don’t. With Dylan, that isn’t so. Part of the brilliance is the potential for reinvention and/or replication by other artists. Hence, he’s probably the most covered artist ever, right? But, there are some I consider to have a very nuanced magic to, specifically, the vocal delivery and cadence, without which a degree of the emotional punch would be lost. I think the best example I can think of is Most of the Time. What do you think are the hardest Dylan tracks to cover/to just sing?”

Others believe a Blonde on Blonde classic is beyond the realm of possibility for most singers, as is a Bringing it All Back Home song. The fan replied: “Visions of Johanna is actually really, really hard to sing right. The vocal leaps in It’s All Over Now Baby Blue are also challenging. And I’ve always thought Tangled Up in Blue is hard to get right without sounding like a parody.”

Another comment reads: “Tell Me Momma. It is such a perfect representation of that ’66 tour in terms of energy and sound, and it has that often imitated ‘Dylan voice’. Since he never sang it live or in studio again (as far as we know), we only have that version. With other songs from that time, we have seen them change and evolve over the years, sung in different tempos and styles, but not that one.

“When people try to cover or copy that iteration of Dylan, it always sounds like parody, and trying to capture the energy and magic of Dylan from that tour is a fool’s errand. It was practically otherworldly.”

A third fan added: “Cannot believe Like A Rolling Stone hasn’t been mentioned – have heard some truly awful covers and the snarl and disdain Dylan sings with and which the song needs are so uniquely him.”

Others believe some of Dylan’s songs can show who can and can’t sing, with Desire song One More Cup of Coffee (Valley Below) singled out by one listener. They wrote: “You can’t sing that song if you’re a bad singer. It’s definitely one that shows he can sing.”


Discover more from Cult Following

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Ewan Gleadow
Ewan Gleadowhttps://cultfollowing.co.uk/
Editor in Chief at Cult Following

READ MORE

LEAVE A REPLY

LATEST