Perhaps the boldest move Justin Timberlake would ever make was wearing triple denim. Nothing will ever come close to this gutsy move. His eighteen-track latest, Everything I Thought It Was, certainly lacks the commitment to horror he had twenty-three years ago. There is a striking lack of relevancy to Timberlake – who mounts his comeback by pairing with NYSNC members on Paradise. It is closer to the end of this record, because who else would slog through the sixteen tracks before it? He lost his voice making heartbreak pretty, or at least he alleges so on opener Memphis. Was it not the decade in the wilderness of acting which did his music in? Trolls is not a great win for the CV.
Nor is Everything I Thought It Was, either. A greedy look at a man hopeful of his career booming back into place because he hopes to reflect on the days when his music circled the charts. If it were not so out of time it would be quite enjoyable. Entertaining flow and a decent mix to F**kin’ up the Disco is torpedoed by Timberlake. Switch your brain off for No Angels and Play, the latter being as vapid as it is broad. Everything I Thought It Was broadly follows the usual run of contemporary R&B and pop. It blurs together vaguely enough and the few highs found on Everything I Thought It Was come not from singles like generic writings from Drown but the shorter, fleshed-out moments found on the likes of Sanctified.
There is no doubt Timberlake is genuine and hopes to reconnect with the music he left behind, but the ship sailed a decade ago. His latest record is based on name value alone and would struggle to see the light of day, its bang-average bluntness a difficult hurdle to jump. Anything to love about Everything I Thought It Was comes from the lack of vocal additions from Timberlake – it is the mixing which holds these songs in a loftier position than they deserve. Love & War is a horrid back and forth of its positive and negative simplicity found in the title, but reflected as the raging passions of emotive output, something Timberlake struggles to mount himself when penning these jagged pop appealing shells. But he fails to engage his unique qualities, instead mimicking what came before.
Ultimately it marks a mockery of its listeners. An hour and twenty of similar-sounding pop riffs which are built up and brought down better by other artists. Timberlake has nothing new to offer and unless there is a demented and intense interest in his whereabouts, there is little to gauge from Everything I Thought It Was. Tonal indifference as Timberlake tries to get back into the music game. You can already see Timberlake grinding away to What Lovers Do, the flatlining middle-aged views of intimacy and sex come through as vague metaphors and grating explorations of his own mind. Selfish notations throughout should come as no surprise, but they often refer to Timberlake’s partner, the elusive and unnamed, as an object to win and maintain rather than connect with. It is a constant trouble for Everything I Thought It Was, which is everything you should expect from trivial pop returns.
Discover more from Cult Following
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
