HomeMusicAlbumsFoo Fighters - One by One Review

Foo Fighters – One by One Review

Rating: 2 out of 5.

Hit-reliant bands are nothing new, and Foo Fighters carried the torch Queen and ABBA did in the 1970s and 1980s. The Dave Grohl-fronted band has released some truly popular works this century, and those songs will stick in the mind through cultural osmosis whether we like it or not. But their best can be found in the tail end of the 1990s. My Hero still makes for a mighty impact, though the same cannot be said for the songs that followed. One by One, particularly, feels like an unremarkable step into the twenty-first century for Foo Fighters. Their first album of the 2000s would set a low bar of quality that Grohl and the band would rarely, if ever, overcome. Where the band may soar on moments throughout The Colour and the Shape, the emotional context which holds part of the album together is repeated here, and worse. But even then, there’s a comfort to One by One. 

That comes through nostalgia. Nobody can truly head back into this album, particularly opening song All My Life, and not have that flood of sentiment. It’s not for the song, it’s for moments where the track was present, which is everywhere since Foo Fighters in the early and mid-2000s were inescapable. For the memories alone, it’s worth returning to that rock and roll classic. It defines the times without ever saying that much. “Onto the next one,” the song ends with, and that is the mentality Grohl and the band has for One by One. There’s no real overlap of themes or a sense of storytelling from song to song, it’s just a hits parade of heavier rock and roll which the group had shown their skill for on previous releases. They’re clearly capable with this sound, but the writing is beyond horrendous. Clunky love songs like Have it All warn of being drained, though the music will drain a listener just fine. Emotionally light doesn’t apply, it’s emotionally absent work from the band. 

But then that’s been the point of Foo Fighters’ work, and particularly with One by One, it feels like escapism is the aim. You can still escape with a meaning intact, but Grohl doesn’t sound all that interested in pursuing such a notion. Some of the writing is Oasis levels of poor, that slow cannonball of Champagne Supernova has instilled a confidence in the most redundant of writers. Enjoy the spoils of the one-lane motorway, which Grohl features on Times Like These as a throwaway line which sticks in the head just because of how dense a comment it is. Foo Fighters are defined here not by the instrumental work, steady and somewhat plodding as it may be, but by the groan-inducing writing. Their messages may be escapism from the humdrum of life, but they exist in the humdrum space too, co-existing with those very notions they wish to break down.  

One by One never has the killer instinct of Everlong or the frankly excellent in comparison debut album. Foo Fighters’ desire to just exist, to press the same few buttons of rock and roll, is pathetic. Plodding songs like Halo are inevitable. Nice enough instrumental work, that focus on percussion a little too loud there, but the rest of the album is that fine line between unremarkable and inoffensive. To Grohl and the band’s credit, they specialise in that easy-going flow. Real thuds and grumblings throughout One by One, which has the nerve to trick listeners into thinking it’ll be filled with strong work thanks to an opening track which still features in their setlist today. What follows is by-the-numbers rock music which Grohl cannot adapt anywhere further, a shame since he was so instrumental in this sound.  


Discover more from Cult Following

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Ewan Gleadow
Ewan Gleadowhttps://cultfollowing.co.uk/
Editor in Chief at Cult Following

READ MORE

LEAVE A REPLY

LATEST