Fans have selected an unlikely song from progressive rock band Pink Floyd‘s backlog as “the most beautiful” song they released.
Despite classics like The Great Gig in the Sky and Comfortably Numb being available for selection, listeners believe a song without Roger Waters‘ involvement is the emotional high point. Longtime listeners have since shared their love for High Hopes, a song which featured on The Division Bell. It would be the band’s final album release until The Endless River two decades later. A post to the r/ifyoulikeblank subreddit had a music lover looking for songs similar to this performance of High Hopes from David Gilmour. Many comments were left praising not just this version of the song, but the studio version also.
A user posted: “I genuinely think High Hopes by Pink Floyd is one of the most beautiful pieces of music ever written. David Gilmour’s steel guitar, the backing vocals, the orchestral instruments, the synth work, everything. What other songs by whomever have a large assembly of instruments and singers like this?”
One fan of the track replied with a few suggestions for similar-sounding songs. They wrote: “Grew up on Pink Floyd, High Hopes has been one of my favourite songs for decades. This is a tough one. There are a couple songs I can recommend that are in the ballpark, but nothing that’s a perfect fit, I feel.”
Their song recommendations were Faith in Others by Opeth, Life is an Ocean by Blackfield, and Hybrid by Break My Soul. Another listener shared their experience of listening to High Hopes for the first time, saying they felt their brain “expanding” the more they listened.
They shared: “I remember when I was a kid, I had a stereo next to my bed. I liked to put on headphones and listen to the radio in absolute darkness. One day I was shocked. It was the first time I listened to Pink Floyd and it was an out-of-body experience!
“Listen to all the sounds and the completely different music in absolute darkness while lying down, it was like a psychedelic trip, like my brain was expanding. I was eight years old at the time. Never forgot it.”
Not everyone was a fan of Gilmour’s rousing single from The Division Bell, with one person suggesting the frontman couldn’t sing. They wrote: “It’s a great song, but man, he can’t sing for shit.
“Pink Floyd is one of my favourite bands, and honestl,y the vocals are always what I like the least, either Waters or Gilmour, doesn’t matter, not great. Especially compared to the rest, which is sublime. Pink Floyd deserved better vocalists for sure.”
Another user disagreed, adding: “I think both singers are incredible in technique and voice and emotion. I love them. I’m usually kinda harsh abt singers too. I don’t understand your comparison statement either.”
Discover more from Cult Following
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
