Though Empire Burlesque may split fans, some are defending the Bob Dylan release as a “great record” with just one major flaw.
Released in 1985, Dylan’s efforts on Empire Burlesque featured Tom Petty and The Heartbreakers as he chased a pop-oriented sound. The album was released to mixed reviews at the time and while some of the songs are regarded highly, there are few who would consider it among Dylan’s best releases. A small contingent of fans on the r/BobDylan subreddit, however, believe it is a “great record” with one problem preventing it from reaching the legendary status Highway 61 Revisited and Time Out of Mind received. A user of the subreddit asked: “How bad really is Empire Burlesque? I’ve already been through the generic Dylan stuff, and some more, and I’m thinking about going into the deep ends?
“Currently Empire Burlesque is on my radar. Clean Cut Kid came up on Spotify recently, wasn’t all that bad. So, an honest question, how bad really is it?” Fans of Dylan remain split on the album though say a “remix” of the album could give it a second wind.
One user suggested: “It’s a great record that suffers from being overproduced. The drums are very 80s-sounding. The songs are great. Better than some of the following albums. Someday someone will remix Empire Burlesque and all the haters will say, ‘Hey, this one is pretty good.”
Some of those remixed tracks can be found on the official Bootleg Series release, Springtime in New York. Another user added: “Yeah, strong songwriting, dated and kinda cheesy production (except for Dark Eyes).” A third added: “Overproduction. Great record that Dylan wanted to sound like an 80s record. It does. I love it. It was the first contemporary Dylan album I bought.”
Other users have since said Empire Burlesque “rocks” and offers a “different type” of Dylan, as many of his releases to follow also would. One fan wrote: “Empire Burlesque rocks! It’s a different type of Dylan, for sure, but it’s amazing.
“Pair that with the Springtime in New York bootleg and if you haven’t yet, listen to Infidels too. An amazing time in Dylan’s career. Has Anybody Seen My Love and Emotionally Yours are some great standouts.” Another added: “It’s great! I love it because it’s a great example of Dylan shining through regardless of the production/genre/whatever.
“On a cursory listen, it sounds like a tragically bad 80s album, a great artist folding to the conventions of the time. But you keep listening, and it’s still very Dylan! The lyrics, the guitar, the phrasing, etc. Then you get to the end, and you get Dark Eyes – an absolute all-timer.”
Not everyone was taken with Empire Burlesque, though, as a few detractors noted it had just “three great songs” and was a “solid album” overall. The user wrote: “It’s a solid album. Got three great songs on it, Tight Connection to My Heart, When the Night Comes Falling From the Sky, and Something’s Burning, Baby. Never Gonna Be the Same Again and Dark Eyes are also good.”
Another user added: “It’s the one album my opinion has turned on the most. I used to hate it, now I think it’s pretty good. It’s the subsequent two albums I can’t get into.” Knocked Out Loaded and Down in the Groove, the two albums to follow Empire Burlesque, remain two of Dylan’s worst-received albums.
Discover more from Cult Following
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
