Don McLean has reduced the mind to mush. His latest album, American Boys, is like a claw hammer blow to the back of the head. Trying to tackle this new studio effort is impossible. The title-track opener has a Catcher in the Rye telling Mark David Chapman to kill John Lennon effect. Its rotting instrumentals, the heavy pangs of piano and this stylish imitation of an era McLean was a part of yet sounds so distant from now is like inputting the launch codes to a dud nuclear warhead. Making sense of its anti-drugs and ineffectual aim is impossible. McLean sounds as though he did not exist in a time before or after American Pie and rejects the fact of heavy-set drug usage as a cultural indicator in a time when his music was most popular. How he has separated himself from the real world so effectively is a fascinating achievement, yet it means the likes of The Ballad of George Floyd and Mexicali Gal exist.
We are worse off for hearing it as he lays down slick riffs and constantly enduring acoustic guitar work. He has the ultimate luxury of these projects being heard by few but engaged with by those who cannot move on to the next steps of musical interest. McLean speaks for those who are already on his side, the fence-sitting opportunities found throughout this tame and toothless experience are of no real interest, yet it remains fascinating that McLean benefits from a solid vocal range still. Ultimately this is an album trying and failing to capture the day the music died once more. McLean’s heart is in the right place, but his head is removed from the real world, and it fundamentally changes the context of the album. An impossible to infiltrate album because eventually, you hit a point where the ideas offered up by an artist are no longer evolving. Repetitive snoozes like Truth and Fame feel impossible to penetrate for they remain lyrically flatlining yet are moved on by a solid vocal performance.
It is the same trouble Van Morrison has experienced with his cover albums of the last year. McLean claimed people do not express themselves for fear of being blacklisted. In the case of American Boys, McLean does not detail the joys and shortcomings for he has nothing worth expressing. McLean has provided another batch of songs which are culturally relevant in their adaptation but empty of sincerity. “I don’t want to be some pain in the ass with a million opinions who gets on stage and philosophizes, but I will say a little something then sing a tune or two,” he told American Songwriter. Therein is a fundamental failure as an artist and it can be heard in American Boys, even if the instrumental charm and vocal strength is consistent. McLean fears responsibility, that much is clear. He lost the best of himself anyway. He admits as much on I Shall Find My Way, ironically the strongest part of this album.
Mexicali Gal is a burst of laughter, and The Ballad of George Floyd misses the fundamental facts of its brutality. McLean tries to reinvent himself as the stoic voice of the voiceless and lacks the quality, control or braveness necessary to do so. Instead, he lingers on border romances and the perils of having too much money on Vacant Luxury which sounds more like the first few notes of the Fraiser theme than anything else. McLean straddles the line between niche cultural footnotes like Felix Unger and an attempt to take a pop at the modern world and all its shortcomings. A Coronavirus mention appears out of the blue on The Meanest Girl, one of many tracks which has no feel for the real world or a solid pace. He offers neither a solution to the troubles nor an understanding of it and instead finds himself dirtying his hands with topics he does not understand. Take Marley’s Song (Save Yourself) and run. His defence of it being relevant but not of interest to his politically pasteurised audience does not hold water, and nor does American Boys.
Discover more from Cult Following
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Shall we say you quite liked it?